We didn’t even know there was going to be a pizza throwdown. But upon opening up the paper today we learned that Pizzeria Caldera has been named the best pizzeria in Jackson Hole in an article in today’s Jackson Hole News&Guide. While we are a Napoletana-style pizzeria and we pride ourselves on our traditional 12-inch pies, the reporter had judged us on our slice pies, which use the exact same ingredients but don’t always belie just how good the 12-inch pies can be fresh out of the oven.
And these unsolicited, unannounced reviews can certainly be the luck of the draw. It could have been that we had a newbie on the line that day and gone down in flames. As it was, the reporter happened to come in on a day when Katie, one of our top pizzaioli, was getting creative with a BLT pie, laying down her creativity with a little extra TLC, no doubt.
Nonetheless, we managed to edge out the competition, bolstering our belief (despite what another local publication reports every year) that Pizzeria Caldera really is the best pizza in Jackson Hole. We’ll take it!